The first in a series of questions being asked to the ESV translation oversight committee has been posted on Adrian Warnock’s blog today.
The following questions was asked to the committee.
It is of note that the group of scholars who wrote the ESV include some great giants of evangelicalism. I wonder how important to the accurate translation of the Bible is an evangelical faith. How much does the doctrine one believes in influence the act of translation and the philosophy which lies behind it?
If you want to, you can read the text of the reply, or watch a video of a member of the committee answering it.
In short, the answer is: no. But the reasoning given is solid.
My thoughts:
It seems that the question that is being answered here is a question of trust.
Can we trust the translators to be faithfully transmitting God’s word, or should we be suspicious that they are pushing some doctrinal agenda.
I feel that plurality on the translation oversight committee really helps guard against pushing a doctrinal agenda, but then, I am coming at this from an evangelical viewpoint.
I can see where it would be difficult for those outside of the evangelical community to trust that a translation committee that contains some “great giants of evangelicalism” would not be pushing an agenda.
Whether or not such an agenda actually exists is another question entirely.
How’s that for a postmodern view on the issue ;)
Incidentally, in order to spur discussion, the ESV publishers are offering a chance to win a free ESV bible. You are entered every time you comment on the site. However, this topic is dear to my heart and fascinating to me anyway. I hope I’m not participating solely for selfish reasons :)










June 15, 2005
5 Comments