I finally got around to seeing Kingdom of Heaven last night with Dave Powers (to celebrate our birthdays…)
Weak.
I LOVE movies of this genre, the epic “knights doing battle against the forces of evil” gets me every time. The problem is, the core message of this movie is: “Religion is dumb, can’t we all just get along?”. It stopped short of having Orlando Bloom (Baliam) assemble a “diverse”, “multicultural”, army of Jews, Muslims, and Christians, to fight against the evil religious fanatics for freedom and justice.
Now, I agree that religion, in the sense it was portrayed here, is ridiculous. Insane men shouting “God wills it!” to justify whatever it was they wanted to do (in this case, get slaughtered by superior forces), is just… dumb. There was one money scene that made the whole movie worth it though.
In their last stand against the Saracen horde, the defenders of Jerusalem are preparing for the final assault on the city. The coward “bishop” astutely observes, “You have no knights. how can you win a battle without knights?”. Legolas Orlando Bloom agrees, and proceeds to knight any man in the city that can carry a weapon, uttering what should have been a rather inspiring speech. But since it was delivered by an elf instead of Mel Gibson or Maximus, it was just… weak. However, after knighting every man in the city, morale rose by like 1000%.
The coward-”bishop” sneers “Who are you? Do you think you can change the World? Does making a man a knight make him a better fighter? ” Orlando looks around at the ragtag band of new knights, who you can tell feel like a million bucks, and says “Yes.”
Indeed.
Make a man a knight and you make him a better fighter.
Beautiful.
Update: There were several other scenes that I thought were excellent upon reflection.
Bishop: Convert to Islam… repent later!
Balian: You’ve taught me a lot about religion, your Eminence.
Hospitaller: I put no stock in religion. By the word religion I have seen the lunacy of fanatics of every denomination be called the will of god. Holiness is in right action, and courage on behalf of those who cannot defend themselves, and goodness. What god desires is here
[points to head]
and here
[points to heart]
and by what you decide to do every day, you will be a good man. Or not.
Balian: These men would die for what the Pope would have them do?
Hospitaller: Yes, but not Christ, I think…











November 16, 2006
28 Comments